Research reveals contrasting consequences of a warmer Earth
4th September 2012
Analysis of fossil and geological records going back 540 million years suggests that biodiversity on Earth generally increases as the planet warms.
But the research says that the increase in biodiversity depends on the evolution of new species over millions of years, and is normally accompanied by extinctions of existing species. The researchers, from the Universities of York, Glasgow and Leeds, suggest that present trends of increasing temperature are unlikely to boost global biodiversity in the short term because of the long timescales necessary for new forms to evolve. Instead, the speed of current change is expected to cause diversity loss.
The study which is published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) says that while warm periods in the geological past experienced increased extinctions, they also promoted the origination of new species, increasing overall biodiversity.
The new research is a refinement of an earlier study that analysed biodiversity over the same time interval, but with a less sophisticated data set, and concluded that a warming climate led to drops in overall diversity. Using the improved data that are now available, the researchers re-examined patterns of marine invertebrate biodiversity over the last 540 million years.
Lead author, Dr Peter Mayhew, of the Department of Biology at York, said: "The improved data give us a more secure picture of the impact of warmer temperatures on marine biodiversity and they show that, as before, there is more extinction and origination in warm geological periods. But, overall, warm climates seem to boost biodiversity in the very long run, rather than reducing it."
Dr Alistair McGowan, of the School of Geographical and Earth Sciences at the University of Glasgow said: "The previous findings always seemed paradoxical. Ecological studies show that species richness consistently increases towards the Equator, where it is warm, yet the relationship between biodiversity and temperature through time appeared to be the opposite. Our new results reverse these conclusions and bring them into line with the ecological pattern."
Professor Tim Benton, of the Faculty of Biological Sciences at the University of Leeds, added: "Science progresses by constantly re-examining conclusions in the light of better data. Our results seem to show that temperature improves biodiversity through time as well as across space. However, they do not suggest that current global warming is good for existing species. Increases in global diversity take millions of years, and in the meantime we expect extinctions to occur."
Last 3 months. View all
Vas Ponnambalam, Leverhulme Trust (1/09/2013), £245,031
Darren Tomlinson, Leverhulme Trust (1/09/2013), £5,645
Michelle Peckham, Gareth Howell, Roman Tuma, David Beech, Nigel Hooper, MRC (1/05/2013), £893,675
Sarah Calaghan, Derek Steele, BHF (1/05/2013), £208,005
Neil Messenger, EPSRC (1/04/2013), £618,675
Lars Jeuken, BBSRC (1/04/2013), £300,633
Ian Wood, Dunhill Medical Trust (1/04/2013), £113,705
Paul Millner, Wellcome Trust (1/04/2013), £40,000
Andrew Macdonald, Yorkshire Kidney Research Fund (1/04/2013), £39,886
Samit Chakrabarty, Royal Society (1/04/2013), £15,000
Sarah Zylinski, Royal Society (1/04/2013), £11,000
Urwin, Howard Atkinson, BBSRC (1/03/2013), £626,738
Charlotte Haigh, Wellcome Trust (1/03/2013), £50,000
Jim Deuchars, Leeds Teaching Hospitals Charitable Foundation (1/03/2013), £34,618
Carrie Ferguson, Wellcome Trust (1/03/2013), £27,700
Viewing last 3 months | View all items
Declines in the biodiversity of pollinating insects and wild plants have slowed in recent years, according to a new study. more
New research looks at how the management of farms and agricultural landscapes impacts on both pollinators of crops and natural enemies of crop pests. more
A key building block in the virus, which causes birth defects and stillbirths in sheep, goats and cattle, could be targeted by anti-viral drugs. more
A faculty-led study, published in the journal Ecology Letters, overturns the common assumption that evolution only occurs gradually over hundreds or thousands of years. more